2022-07-22 18:42:36

PCR VS Virgin PET: Who Wins In A Fight?

2022-07-22 18:42:36

We produce both PCR and Virgin PET bottles and jars. So choosing between the two materials is like picking our favorite child.

That said, they are each uniquely suited to specific brands and launches.

Let's briefly compare them so you can make a more informed choice for your hair or skin care products.

1. 100% Post Consumer Recycled Material Is More Expensive:

Many people are excited about the ideals and real-life positive impact of using PCR materials.

But few are prepared for the price.

A PCR package does not have to be made from 100% PCR plastic. In other words, it could be a combination of some PCR and some virgin PET. However, after many tests we have discovered that 100% PCR is best for quality control. Plus, used PET material must be collected and sorted from the after-market to make PCR, resulting in higher labor costs than simply making new PET.

Waste reduction isn't just a statement. If you want that benefit, it will cost more.

2. Virgin PET Is Standardized & Has Higher Clarity:

While both have a glass-like look, PET plastic is high-clarity and (if you choose the option) can be completely clear. 

The PCR material has charming original colors. But the "natural" version is milky rather than clear. Due to the process, there is also color variation from package to package. Of course, depending on how you want to frame your marketing, this variance could be used as an advantage (eg. "each piece is unique").

3. Both Can Be Done In "Heavy Wall" Luxury Style:

Neither material involves any compromise on beauty. So that is one way they are the same.

Both are shatterproof, with a sturdy feel in the hand. They have a commanding presence on the shelf. They can be easily customized by spray color coating, printing, and hot stamping.

The bottom line is that, if your brand story involves reducing waste and the Green lifestyle, then you may have to plan for the higher cost of PCR. Or you can get a fully-recyclable and sustainable PET package for a lower cost (but realize that making new plastic technically adds  to the overall material on the planet, even if it can be reused).

Obviously this is a small space to explore this large topic. 

If you want to go into much greater detail, ask specific questions about your needs, and compare both materials with samples... then we should talk.